Take it to your management · Answers

We need an external Type II REM. How do we choose one, and what should it cost?

Many plants above 50,000 GJ have Type I engineers but no Type II yet, so the first Type II comes from outside. What the rules allow, what to ask before you sign, and what the fee should cover.

A power meter screen showing the three line voltages, around 422 V, during logging.
Field photo: one of our power meters logging a site's supply.

The call usually comes from the plant’s own engineer. The engineer holds Type I and has run the plant for years. The site is well above 50,000 GJ a year. The Energy Commission’s notice says the company needs a Registered Energy Manager (REM) within three months. Above 50,000 GJ, that REM must be Type II, and nobody on the payroll holds Type II yet.

So the search starts, and the offers tend to come in three kinds. A Type II who works full-time as the energy manager at another company, and will sign for a monthly fee. An independent consultant working alone. A firm with a team behind its REM.

All three can meet the rules on paper. They buy very different years.

What do the rules allow?

You can appoint a REM who is not on your payroll. The Regulations set four conditions.

  • The external REM must hold Type II. A Type I registration cannot be used from outside the company.
  • The appointment can run for no more than three years from the date of the notice. The clock starts on the notice, not on the day you sign the REM. If you take the full three months to appoint, about two years and nine months are left.
  • When the term ends, you must appoint a REM from your own staff immediately. The Regulations give no grace period.
  • An external REM can act for no more than seven other energy consumers at the same time.

You notify the Commission electronically once you appoint. For groups there is one more route. A REM employed by one company can also act for up to seven related companies in the same group, as long as they hold the type your site needs. The Regulations set no time limit on that route. Check it before you look outside.

P.U.(A) 466/2024, reg. 4(4), 5(b), 6(1) to 6(4) and 14(2) to 14(3).

Path for an external REM. Day 0: the notice. By month 3: the external Type II REM is appointed. Year 1: your own engineer, who holds Type I, joins the committee work. From year 2: the engineer can apply for Type II. By year 3, three years from the notice, the external term ends and your own REM must be appointed immediately.
How three years with an external REM can run, from the notice to your own REM.

What are you paying for?

A REM is more than a registration number on a form. The Act puts the duties on the REM in person, and the Commission’s guideline spells out the year. The REM analyses at least twelve months of energy data from before the appointment, then keeps the analysis going. The energy management system has to run. The committee meets at least four times a year, and top management holds a review at least once. The EE&C report is checked against the actual bills before it goes in. We list each duty in our piece on the first 90 days after the notice.

A REM who fails these duties faces a fine of up to RM20,000. The company has its own fines, of up to RM50,000. Registration is easy to check on the Commission’s register. The harder question is who does the work, and when.

Act 861, s.5(2) to 5(4) and s.7(3). GP/ST/No.47/2024 (Pind. 1/2026), para 3.

Five questions to ask before you sign

  1. How many other appointments do you hold, and what is your day job? The legal limit is seven other energy consumers. A Type II who already works full-time as the energy manager at another company has the least time of all. Their own employer comes first. One person carrying a full-time job and several outside appointments is a heavy load, and the work shows it.
  2. Who does the work between the meetings? The meetings are five visits a year. The data, the meeting papers, the targets and the EE&C report take far more. Ask whether the REM does it alone, has a team behind them, or expects your staff to do it. Any of these can work if it is agreed in writing.
  3. What exactly does the fee cover? The basic fee should cover every duty the REM carries personally. That includes setting up the energy management system in year one, not only the yearly report. Otherwise the REM signs for work nobody was paid to do. Extra services, such as finding saving measures, talking to suppliers or training your team, can sit on a higher tier.
  4. What happens if the REM leaves? You must tell the Commission within 14 days, or face a fine of up to RM10,000. The replacement must come from your own staff within three months, unless the Commission gives written permission for another external REM. Ask who sends the 14-day notice, and whether a named second person can step in.
  5. How will our own engineer take over? At the end of the term, you must appoint your own REM immediately. A Type I engineer can apply for Type II after one year as Type I with a valid practising certificate. So name the engineer in year one, and ask the external REM to bring them into the committee work from the start.

P.U.(A) 466/2024, reg. 6(3), 7(1) to 7(4) and 14(2). GP/ST/No.47/2024 (Pind. 1/2026), para 3.

What should it cost?

Start with what a Type II on your own payroll would cost. Count the salary, the employer’s EPF, SOCSO and EIS contributions, the HRD levy where it applies, and the months it takes to find one. Then add the risk that the engineer resigns and the 14-day clock starts again. That total is the fair comparison.

A fee far below it usually buys fewer hours. Check the hours against the duties above. Three things settle most of the price. How often does the REM attend? Is setting up the energy management system inside the fee? Who writes the EE&C report?

Why an outside REM can help with management

An employee REM reports to the same managers who set the budget. An outside REM sits in the management review as a professional from another firm. They can say plainly that a target is too soft, or that next year’s measures need money. The plants we work with tell us that management hears it differently when it comes from outside.

Use it. Ask the external REM to present the year’s numbers at the management review, and to put next year’s budget for saving measures on the table.

What to do this week

  1. Find the notice date. Add three months for the appointment and three years for the external term.
  2. Check the site’s energy use against 50,000 GJ. Below that line, your own Type I engineer can be the REM, and you may not need an outside one at all. The free threshold checker on eeca2024.my converts bills to GJ.
  3. If the company is part of a group, check whether a REM employed in a related company can act for you.
  4. Send each candidate the five questions above, and ask for the answers in writing.
  5. Name the engineer who will take over, and start their path to Type II.
  6. Keep the energy data, the minutes and the energy management system files on your own system, so the next REM inherits a complete record.

Where Innovast fits

Innovast Sdn Bhd is a Registered ESCO with Suruhanjaya Tenaga (ESCO 327(2023)/76/2024), with Registered Energy Auditors and Registered Energy Managers on staff. We provide external Type II REMs, with our team doing the data, the meeting papers and the EE&C report behind the REM. The fee starts from RM3,500 a month, on a twelve-month minimum, for the quarterly committee meetings and the management review. More frequent attendance and hands-on extras, such as finding saving measures and training your team, cost more. From the first month we plan the handover to your own engineer.

See the external REM serviceCheck your threshold on eeca2024.my

Revised Nov 2026 against Act 861, P.U.(A) 466/2024 and GP/ST/No.47/2024 (Pind. 1/2026).

EECA Watch · free

Get new pieces in your inbox.